Saturday, June 13, 2009

Wikipedia Comparison

For my comparison I looked at the article about the Boston Massacre on Wikipedia as well as the Encyclopedia Britannica website. I was very surprised by what I found. I have never allowed my students to use Wikipedia as a resource because I had been told that the information was very unreliable. When I read both of these articles I was amazed that the Wikipedia article gave a lot more in depth information about this topic. The encyclopedia Britannica article gave very little information. This article also had a list of other entries that you could go to that were related to this event. With this event especially I can see Wikipedia being a great resource because this is an event that has a lot of speculation around it. The Wikipedia article talked about a lot of the theories people have about the events that took place. Encyclopedias and Text books leave these out because they are not proven facts. However, they can bring a deeper understanding about the event.

After looking that these two article I found that I preferred the article on Wikipedia because it had a lot more detailed information and everything that I needed to know was in one spot. This has shown me that this could be a great resource for my students. Before I allowed my class to use this as a resource I would talk with them about how Wikipedia works and let them know that it is important to check the facts that they find. I also think that I would give them an article or a list of articles to look at. This way I would be able to make sure they were looking at accurate information.

Links to Changes that I have made on Wikipedia

English
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Shigley618

Simple English
http://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Shigley618

No comments:

Post a Comment